Wednesday 23 May 2018

CorkHi16°| Lo

Cork Independent

Letters to the Editor

Catholic church is not to blame entirely for tuam babies

Thursday, 19th June, 2014 1:00am

Dear Editor,


The story of the babies' cemetery in Tuam has revealed a rather schizophrenic streak within Irish society. There has been considerable outrage and cries of 'shame!' and perhaps not without reason. It seems a little unfair however that today's public can heap such opprobrium on nuns who were asked by Irish society to take on this task when it was Irish society - families and courts - who sent these girls to Mother and Baby Homes in the first place because they did not want them around. It seems equally unfair to specifically blame the Catholic Church, considering such homes operated under similar, or worse, conditions in the Protestant UK.

It would be more honest to acknowledge these homes, along with workhouses and Magdalene laundries, came into existence precisely because of a new middle-class that emerged in Victorian times and craved 'respectability' above all else.

The Free State continued to operate what it had inherited from the Empire after 1922. Insofar as 'religion' had any role, it was because it came to be another expression of the brand of 'respectability' so beloved of the Victorian bourgeoise. So much for history, what about today? Whilst decrying past attitudes, a cursory glance at any opinion forums of today will also reveal a degree of antipathy towards single mothers. Whereas Victorian middle-class 'religious' morality may have played a role in the past, today's antipathy is rooted in baser motives - sheer economic miserliness.

Many are deeply resentful about supporting single mothers through taxes and welfare payments. Underlying these economic arguments are also thinly-veiled secular moral ones: single mothers tend to be portrayed as workshy, fraudulent, lazy and unhealthy. If one is not willing to contribute to the welfare of such mothers and one thinks their condition somehow reprehensible, how can one decry past behaviour towards them, or claim to be so very different to past generations?

At least past generations tried to find some solution, albeit not a very pleasant one. Today's critics simply would 'prefer not to know' - regardless of the consequences to the woman and her child.

My own attitude - even if I think children ideally ought be raised within the security of a marriage - has always been that any woman brave enough to have her child rather than hop on a boat to England deserves my help if she is unable to support the child herself.

I have never resented paying this particular tax for that reason, though absentee fathers definitely ought to be brought to account and pay their fair share.


Yours sincerely,

Nick Folley



ePaper Service

Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 Page 7 Page 8
Desktop, Tablet & Smartphone friendly
Cookies on Cork Independent website
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. We also use cookies to ensure we show you advertising that is relevant to you. If you continue without changing your settings, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on the Cork Independent website. However, if you would like to, you can change your cookie settings at any time by amending your browser settings.
How does Cork Independent use cookies?
Cookies enable us to identify your device, or you when you have logged in. We use cookies that are strictly necessary to enable you to move around the site or to provide certain basic features. We use cookies to enhance the functionality of the website by storing your preferences, for example. We also use cookies to help us to improve the performance of our website to provide you with a better user experience.
We don't sell the information collected by cookies, nor do we disclose the information to third parties, except where required by law (for example to government bodies and law enforcement agencies).
Hide Message