Skip to content

Cork Independent

Home arrow Sections arrow Sport arrow Interesting Statistics
Interesting Statistics E-mail
Written by Staff Reporter   
Thursday, 11 October 2007
Much has been written about the recent All-Ireland football final. Most of it makes grim reading for supporters of Cork football. Much of it had been plain nonsense. It is very easy to apportion blame. Destructive criticism is the easiest of all. Constructive criticism is far more difficult and that, I suppose, is why it is in much shorter supply. The team management has come in for criticism, and rightly so, in the area of the team selected and for being so naive in their tactical approach but there is a deeper malaise when one stands back and studies the whole football scene in the biggest county of all.

Now, Cork has won the last four Munster under 21 titles, beating Kerry, on the way, on three occasions. The exception was this year when Kerry were sensationally eliminated by unfancied Clare in the first round. Despite this only one Cork player from that four year period of dominance was included in the team that started the All-Ireland final!  That was Michael Shields. Yet, six players from the same period were handed the green and gold jersey. The same applied to the substitutes listed.

Kerry players, from that era, outnumbered those of Cork - 8 to 6. It may have been even more as I have reason to believe that it was a promising young player who made way for Anthony Lynch's inclusion in the substitutes. It surely gives plenty of food for thought. We must ask the question, what happens to so many of our promising young players? Are they neglected? Are they made to feel that they are not wanted? Are we over loyal to older players who have been given their opportunity and failed to deliver? Are we making the best use of the concept of the extended panel? I have always opposed that concept and for many reasons --- it devalues the All-Ireland medal, it adds further chaos to club competitions and, dare I say it, on the grounds of the financial burden it places on county committees. Its one redeeming feature, where I am concerned, is that it allows team management to bring young promising players on board and gradually introduce them to what is required at senior level. Kerry seem to be doing that but, sadly, in Cork it does not appear to be the case. It is time for a change. It would be one step in the right direction.

Some scribes have been pedalling the idea that this Cork team is still a very young one. Indeed members of the management play the same tune. Of course, it is just a smokescreen. The reality is than on average the Kerry fifteen that started in Croke Park is one year younger than that of Cork. The same applies to the fifteen listed substitutes! Sure, they may have more miles on the clock but there are some Cork players who have also travelled many miles in their county's cause.

The point is that we should face reality and not be deluding ourselves and sticking our heads in the sand. There is a big job to be done if this Cork team is to be resurrected. There are men on that team who deserve nothing but the best. They have given their all over a long number of years in the cause of the jerseys they wear. It must be galling for them to see inferior players, from across the county bounds, pocketing All-Ireland medals while they can but stand by and watch. The least the players can expect is that the members of the team management all pull together in the same direction and if only half of the rumours, now circulating, are to be believed that does not seem to have been so in the year just gone by. In fact the direct opposite would appear to have been the case. The real losers in these situations are the players. That is the unfortunate reality. I have had experience of being part of happy selection commitments and, sadly, of also being involved in one that were not so happy. Invariably the happy ones were the successful ones. Players are the first to sense when all is not well and it generally tends to have the effect of ensuring that an air of gloom pervades the whole camp. It can be most destructive. Abraham Lincoln was right when he famously said on the issue of slavery, “A house divided against itself cannot stand.” It takes everybody pulling together to have any chance of winning an All-Ireland. Divided and fragmented the chances are virtually nil. Team managements should put the interests of the players above and beyond their own egos. These are the men who really count at the end of the day. Considering the effort they are asked to put in these days they deserve nothing but the best.


Comments (0) »
feed


Write the displayed characters


busy
 
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 
Share:
Digg
Delicious
NewsVine
Reddit
Technorati
YahooMyWeb
Spurl
< Prev

Visit our Games and puzzles section